The proposal to eliminate taxes on overtime wages and tips, initially a highlight of President Donald Trump’s 2024 campaign, appears to be falling short as the Senate pushes back against it.

Big Beautiful BILL: The Good, Bad, and Ugly
The push to remove taxes on tipped wages began as a simple statement made during a rally last summer, but has since attracted attention from both political sides. Senators Catherine Cortez Masto and Jacky Rosen praised it as beneficial for Nevada’s tourism workers, while even many within the GOP, including Senator Ted Cruz, labeled it a laudable tax cut. However, critics argue this proposal may do more harm than good.

“No Tax on Tips and No Tax on Overtime are popular no-brainer policies.” — Alex Pfeiffer (@Pfeiffer47)
Link to Tweet

Despite the popularity of tax-free tips sounding appealing to workers, the specifics reveal limitations. Eligibility requirements and payroll taxes would remain, adding complexity rather than simplicity.

The Senate’s Surprise Vote
Senator Lindsey Graham has hinted that the tax-free policy might be better placed within a standalone bill rather than this broader legislation. Concerns about incorporating all of Trump’s propositions arise, indicating a lack of cohesion within the party.

What’s Next?
The fate of the Big Beautiful Bill now lies in the hands of the GOP as it heads to the Senate. While it has the potential to offer significant financial relief for service industry workers, effective implementation depends on essential agreements among lawmakers.