A new proposal aimed at implementing a soft fork for Bitcoin has generated significant controversy on X, primarily due to its inclusion of potential legal consequences for those opting out of the proposal.

Formulated by core developer Luke Dashjr and shared publicly on Friday, this enhancement is at the center of an ongoing debate between Bitcoin Core supporters and those advocating for its alternatives, particularly focusing on permissible uses of Bitcoin and whether certain types of transactions should be filtered. The proposal suggests enforcing restrictions on data within Bitcoin (BTC) transactions through a one-year soft fork as discussions continue to prevent the embedding of harmful content into the blockchain, especially highlighted since the latest Bitcoin Core update.

Critics of the proposal argue that its language implies moral and legal impediments against rejecting the soft fork, describing one section as a straightforward legal threat. Bam, a prominent figure in Bitcoin education, labeled the proposal’s wording as “Orwellian,” linking it to George Orwell’s vision of a totalitarian state represented in his book 1984.

Moreover, Ben Kaufman, a software engineer, declared that a fork enforced under the threat of legal action constitutes a blatant attack on the principles of Bitcoin. In addition, Peter Todd commented that the expectations for the proposal’s acceptance are driven by implied legal pressures, adding friction to the conversation.

While several community members have expressed these concerns, there are those who maintain that the proposal has been misinterpreted, speculating that it merely points to the potential liabilities introduced by the recent Bitcoin Core update allowing larger data integrations. Luke Dashjr chimed in, suggesting that the language may need clarification to prevent misunderstandings.

Ultimately, the effectiveness of the proposed soft fork remains uncertain, though it reportedly continues to progress without technical disputes.

Related: Another ‘Satoshi era’ wallet from 2009 has awakened and moved Bitcoin